Part IV: Wandering
And the figurative ball is back in Brant's metaphorical court. Happily,
this section provides matters of biblical interpretation to criticize.
Chapter 16 Hog Time starts with a "folksy story." It's punchline is "Time ain't
nothing to a hog!" Jamie and I
agree that there isn't much point to this story. Daniel suggests that God is
like the farmer, but it occurs to me that "Time ain't nothing to" the
eternal God. What sense do you make of this chapter? Did it speak to you?
Chapter 17 Speaking in Tongues contains the sentence: "On Pentecost the followers of Jesus suddenly
understood one another's languages." (Emphasis mine). What actually
occurred on Pentecost is that Jews from all over the known world heard the
followers of Jesus speaking the Gospel
in their own languages. Some of them then became followers of Jesus.
Other than that, this chapter suggests that we should learn each other's
languages, at least in a metaphorical sense, and hear one another's stories.
Authenticity is more important than (lip-syncing) glitz, I hear Daniel say. Do
you have a story of learning another language?
Have you found shared humanity with someone with whom you thought you had
nothing in common? (Jamie, please note how carefully I avoided ending that sentence with a
preposition).
How does your faith community empower you to witness to your faith?
Chapter 18 The Poor Are Not Lucky describes Daniel's encounter with a self-serving woman who thinks the
"poor are the lucky ones." Oy! What well-meaning theological
statements set your teeth on edge? (Personally I cringe when I hear someone
say "God never gives us more than we can handle.") Can we ever do
good from pure motives? According to Daniel
"'Generosity begets generosity,' Jesus assures us." She would
have to quote me chapter and verse on that.
She ends the chapter with a pointed Benedictine prayer. Do you have a
prayer to share for those who are in need, and for those who work to alleviate
need?
Chapter 19 Please Stop Boring Me is basically a reprise of chapter 1. Daniel writes, "What is
interesting is doing this work in community, where other people might call you
on stuff or, heaven forbid, disagree with you." Jamie and I regularly attend
a Tuesday morning pastors' text study where the participants often disagree and
correct one another. I couldn't help but think that, if Lillian Daniel were a
part of that group, we would take her to task for saying things like "Paul
was a tax collector." Do you have a community that "calls you on
stuff?" Is it your church?
Has the "spiritual but not religious" mindset made its way into
your congregation?
Chapter 20 Animals in the Airport is about our human relations with animals. I was
reminded of an African exchange student
who thought Americans were more in touch with nature than the people of his
country because we have animals--pets--in our homes. The Scriptures tell us
that all of creation is being redeemed by God. Do you have any experience with
animal blessing services? How does Daniel's seeing God at work in dogs, cats,
birds and giraffes differ from teh "spiritual but not religious"
mindset she criticizes? (Thanks, Jamie, for that question). Does your
vision of the Kingdom of God include animals?
Finally, Chapter 21 Immigrants Like Us offers some pointed
criticisms of the plight of immigrants and "our" attitudes toward
"them." What language do you hear in the immigration debates? What
difference does that language make? Is there a way to move forward? Does your
faith inform your position on immigration reform?
Are there flags in your church? Why are they there? Should they be there?
What do you think would happen if they were re/moved?
I hope that these observations and questions will stimulate conversation. What
other issues or questions did this section of the book raise for you? What
observations or stories do you have to offer?
Hog
ReplyDeleteMy first thought after reading this: So what if I’m like the hurrying young man. I’m getting things done! I agreed with the young man’s comment to the farmer about how inefficient the farmer was at moving the hog. If I carried out my work like the farmer, I would soon be out of a job. This was not a good story and I did not like her analogy for God being the farmer.
Speaking
I went to Mexico on 2 church mission trips. My daughter went also. She had taken 2 years of high school Spanish, so she was able to give me a crash course on some Spanish words and phrases. Once in Mexico, she was able to converse quite well with the native people. The children were especially thrilled with her. I suppose they felt joy in the reality that this American cared enough to learn their native language so that she could speak to them.
I was in awe at the fact that the author spent several years in a language class and came out with no understanding!! So far, the first 2 chapters of part 4 are disappointing and unmeaningful for me.
Thanks for your comments, Debbie. You have done a lot to keep this conversation alive.
DeleteLearning to speak someone else's "language" (even if they speak English) involves a lot of listening. Truly hearing someone's story is a way to validate their experience and invite them into the life of the Church.
Although I pick on Daniel's exegesis, I have to say that, at her best, she is insightful and inspiring. At her worst (Hog Time) she is still engaging and entertaining. Always, she is highly readable.
I also agree with her overall theme, which I take to be that Jesus calls us into relationship, not only with himself, but also with other members of his body, the Church. Martin Luther says that the Holy Spirit "calls" and "gathers" Christians into community.
There is a story that Luther was visiting a parishioner who had been absent from worship. Luther took a log from the man's fireplace and set it on the mantle where its fire died. We burn brightest and warmest in community. Apart from the body of Christ, we sputter, grow cold, and die.
Christians need one another.
I agree with your comments. For the most part, this is a thought-provoking book with only a few chapters I could do without. Like I said before, she got me to open my Bible and delve deeper into a story.
DeleteMaybe the children in Mexico were happy with my daughter because she listened and understood them and not because she could speak to them in their language.
Besides the community theme, Daniel’s stories speak to the need for those in a church community to engage and encourage others into the life of the Church.
I agree with the author’s response to the “well-dressed” woman’s comment. It was close to how I would have responded to her
ReplyDeleteAs far as the generosity comment, I had to do some more Bible study:
Paul said in his second letter to the Corinthians 9:6 “Whoever sows sparingly will also reap sparingly and whoever sows generously will also reap generously.”
Proverbs 11:25 says “a generous man will prosper.....”
In Luke 6:38 Jesus comes close with this comment: “Give and it will be given you. A good measure pressed down…”
I love the Celtic prayers for encouragement. Here are two of my favorites:
God with me protecting,
The Lord with me directing,
The Spirit with me strengthening
For ever and for evermore.
The caim or encircling prayer:
Circle (name), Lord
Keep (comfort) near and (discouragement) afar.
Keep (peace) within and (turmoil) out
Insert the words that fit the circumstance into the parenthesis.
I am currently reading another book, Bible Babel by Kristen Swenson. It's pretty basic for someone with a seminary education, but a decent introduction to the Bible and how it is used. At the end of chapter 8, Swenson writes, "Nancy Pelosi meant well when she declared in her 2008 Earth Day speech, 'The Bible tells us in the Old Testament, "To minister to the needs of God's creation is an act of worship. To ignore those needs is to dishonor the God who made us."' Although the general sense of her biblical reference is an acceptable interpretation of some biblical ideas and texts, she seemed to suggest that she was quoting; but no such text exists, and she caught a lot of heat for it."
DeleteI think we have a similar situation with Daniel's statement that Jesus assures us "Generosity begets generosity." It sounds like a quote. It isn't. It is arguably an acceptable interpretation of things Jesus said (e.g. Luke 6:38, as you point out) but I would like to have seen Daniel's work.
I'm persnickety like that.
Boring
ReplyDeleteI agree that this is a repeat of Chapter 1.
Two sentences stood out for me and got me thinking: “Where life with God gets rich and provocative is when you dig deeply into a tradition that you did not invent all for yourself.” And “…someone brave enough to encounter God in a real human community?” From these two sentences, two words stood out: provocative and brave.
I looked up provocative in the thesaurus: tantalizing, intriguing, attractive, arousing, and thrilling. A provocative life with God and digging deeply, I love them both! I would like to have dug deeply enough so that I will feel confident when I am “called on stuff.”
Do we have to be brave to share our knowledge of God’s love in the community? I would prefer to be authentic and confident.
I am still reflecting on these two sentences.
Animals
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed this chapter. I love animals and have had many an adventure with wild ones. We have always had a pet in our house.
I am currently reading the book Zoobiquity:What Animals Can Teach Us About Health and the Science of Healing. I have read Silent Thunder: The Hidden Voice of Elephants and The Wauchula Woods Accord: Toward a New Understanding of Animals.
All 3 books explore the frontier between humans and animals. They are all fascinating and thought provoking.
I think the author was demonstrating the same thing she has in previous chapters with stories and anecdotes, only this time it was with animal stories. Not so much that she sees God in animals, but that the animal human association is a metaphor for us and God.
Immigrants
ReplyDeleteThis was an informative, short history of immigration. I didn't get much out of it other than that.
Now I have to check to see if we have flags in our sanctuary! I honestly don't know for sure. Good questions about the flags, Brant. I wonder if it has ever been a discussion at council?